I filled the entire list for my granddaughter, who's going in to 5th grade this year-much to her mothers' dismay.All supplies go in to a 'community bucket', and are doled out by the teacher. After giving it some thought, I think I may have been a little foolish.... The total came to $168.00 for:
200 3 x 5 lined index cards 1 box of crayons - 24 or more
3 pads of 3 x 3 sticky notes 1 Package of small Post-Its (about 1/2 x 2) 2 dry erase markers
2 reams of printer paper 1 notebook pouch for pencils 1 ruler - inch & centimeter
1 cap and pink erasers 1 hand pencil sharpener with lid 1 large scissors 1
8-10 blue ballpoint pens 1 8-10 red ballpoint pens 2 large boxes of Kleenex
2 yellow highlighters 1 two-inch 3-ring binder with 5 dividers 2 glue sticks 1 backpack - with child’s name on it
I'm pretty sure one child will not use all of these supplies in a school year. I am also aware that teachers make an average of $68,000.00 a year in our area, where the median average is less than $30,000.00. There seems to be a bit of imballance here....
My daughter has chosen to send supplies on an as-needed basis, and keep the remainder at home.'Free' education sure does cost a lot!
After spending $300+ on school supplies last year and my grandson getting to keep only his binder, paper and pencils, I decided to do it (a lot) differently this year. The only thing I've bought for the "communal bucket" is tissue and hand sanitizer. Everything else has his name engraved on it (yes including his pencils).
Think they'll get the message
Jas
You're either part of the solution or part of the problem. There is no middle ground.
'Plastic, not paper': Growing demands for pricey school supplies anger parents Cash-strapped schools across America are demanding that parents spend hundreds on supplies, even requiring bulk purchases of cleaning materials that benefit the entire class, in a move that is fomenting anger among moms who say the lists are real budget busters.
Elizabeth Shatz, a PTA parent from Mineola, N.Y., said she was required to purchase three 20-count boxes of pencils, multiple containers of baby wipes and boxes of tissues to be distributed among her child’s entire classroom. She also had to search store shelves for folders and notebooks in very specific colors – often hard-to-find hues – and was instructed to buy the more expensive “plastic, not paper” variety.
You know, I understand our schools are in financial trouble. I understand there are children who's parents can't afford the supplies. But, doggone it, I can't buy for the whole school. There are programs and sponsors for supplying the children. Heck, those children get more and better supplies than my little one does.
I told the City Council that if our city can afford $100,000,000 on fireworks at 4th of July, then there is enough money to adequately fund the schools. Of course there was an attempted lecture on tourism, and a counter lecture on quality education and job growth.
J
You're either part of the solution or part of the problem. There is no middle ground.
We always ran into the same thing when Quin was younger. It was getting more and more expensive every year with the supply lists. We didn't mind helping with some communal items, but the amounts being asked for were getting outrageous and Quin's school is tiny and they only have 30 or so kids in her entire grade. Even worse was the mid-year letter that came home begging for more class room supplies because they were running out and kids were having to go without. Again, we didn't mind helping if possible, but I made sure that I got enough stuff that my kid didn't run out and we couldn't afford to keep restocking the rest of the students needs.
To be fair, it is a little better now that she is in high school. There isn't the same level of having to buy all of the extra communal items, but there are certainly other things that are pricey replacing those communal things that we aren't needing. Calculators that cost in the hundred or more range and last year driver's ed was $250 and this year between registration and the college class Quin is taking it was about $500 before supply shopping. And we do still get asked to find all of the plastic, oddly colored folders, just that we don't have to buy them for all of the other kids in her class now.
It's obscene for a communal supply pot these days! I remember when I was in school, BTS supplies (communal included) would top out at around $30 or $40 on the cheap. $150 is about average for "cheap" now o.O A friend of mine in another state was lamenting a year or two ago about the FIVE HUNDRED dollars she spent on their BTS list, and it wasn't name brands -- just large amounts of supplies requested. WTF?
Queen of English Language Mangling, Master of the Edit button
We are getting ready to go do our back to school supply shopping this next week and I can almost feel the pain already. The list is still pretty big. I had Quin gather up everything that was left from last year so we could go through and figure out what is reusable for this year. What gets me is that each class has specific colored folders and 3 ring binders that are required, but the colors change from one year to the next between classes. So while math might have been red folders last year, this year they are blue or green and whatever was blue or green last year is something else this year.
I finally put my foot down with the school and said they can just suck it up if my kid's folders don't match whatever this year's colors are because if she has perfectly good folders and binders from last year, I will not be buying brand new ones just because some idiot decided that the colors needed to be switched up and if that was a problem they could pony up some cash because this is not negotiable. They "agreed" that it would be ridiculous to have to buy all brand new things if what we have will work and not to worry about it. I told them that I have so much other stuff I am worrying about right now that their supply OCD madness didn't even make the list of what I was worrying about. I got "No, sure, we completely understand." So, if I milk the drama about my still undiagnosed medical stuff to get out of having to replace perfectly good folders that I can't afford to replace, I feel zero guilt about it.
I totally agree that the schools are gathering supplies off of our backs...(or bucks)
I have been holding extra supplies at home too and have found that I often have leftovers when the school year ends.
For example, they request 3 boxes of kleenex per kid, multiple erasers, pencils, notebooks, etc. I have some leftover from last year that I dont have to buy again this year. If I would have sent them all to the school, then I would have nothing left.
Even registration fees are pretty high, and it includes nothing...just admin fees (159$ per student) I have 3....plus nearly 300$ for uniforms (only for one of my kids thank God)...that is BEFORE going to purchase the necessary supplies on the lists...
simply put, Back to school costs me way more than Chritsmas does!
If this was college, I would understand but high school and elementary school, this is way too expensive and they request way too much stuff.
If my child runs out of something for school ion the middle of the school year, then I go and buy more...that simple.
For crying out loud, they even request a 2 inch binder for Gym class.... WTF
You don't have a soul. You are a soul, you have a body!
oh and Glencairn, I have done the very same thing last year for binders and folders...I write what the subject is on a sticker and they can shove it.... My kids can read so no need to have a specific color for subjects...
I can understand this color system for 1st graders that can barely read, a color code simplifies things for them. but after that, we should be able to chose whatever we want since we pay for it. As long as its identified properly!
You don't have a soul. You are a soul, you have a body!
Exactly! My kid is going into 11th grade, she doesn't need to color code her folders and binders, we can write "math" on it and it doesn't matter what color it is, she's perfectly capable of reading the word and taking the right binder to its proper class. I don't miss the communal pot shopping at all. Even better for Quin, the gym teacher didn't like her (she allowed bullying by the athletes to the less athletic kids and I had to talk to her about my kid coming home bleeding and she kept dodging my requests for a private meeting so I did it very publicly at parent/teacher conferences.) and Quin was able to get an exemption for gym class this year. Admittedly, it's because she is taking physics as well as her regular science class and can't fit gym into her schedule, but Quin is thrilled to not have gym and I'm happy to not have to buy yet another gym uniform as well as a binder - and yes, we needed to provide a binder for gym class, too.